NYC Square Pizza with Vodka Sauce & Cupping Pepperoni

Step 5: Prep the pan, oven, & toppings

Toppings

  • Olive Oil
    for the pan
  • Pepperoni
    1 whole stick
  • Low-moisture mozzarella
    150 g
  • Picante provolone
    50 g

From previous steps

  • Proofed dough

Get out a square metal pizza pan (although a baking sheet will work). Add a drizzle of olive oil to the pan, enough to spread and coat the entire surface.

Toss the dough in and stretch to the edges. If it springs back before reaching the edges of the pan, it will need to rest for a final 10-20 minutes so you can fully stretch it to the corners.

Preheat the oven to 450°F/232°C. Finally, prep the toppings. Grate the cheeses and cut the pepperoni into 36 ~1/8” (3-5mm) slices.

  • If you want to get the cupping pepperoni effect, you can’t use presliced pepperoni and you can’t make the slices too thin (or overly thick).

  • ~1/8” slices seem to be the sweet spot for pepperoni that will curl up during high-heat baking.